Cherryl
This is a peer review board. That means everyone has an opinion they can express and suggestions they can offer. Unfortunately, you will receive some incorrect advice and suggestions. When the experienced members see this, we try to correct the information if it's a real issue, and not just an opinion. But it's the nature of the board that you will see different advice from different people.
Just like the rest of us had to do, you have to decide who you feel comfortable taking advice from and what level of advice. You might feel comfortable with some newer members giving you advice on foods or testing but more comfortable with other, more experienced members for dosing advice, SS interpretation, etc.
What I learned when I was new was that I would not take any advice from anyone who did not have a visible SS. Even though many of us oldtimers have lost our kitties, we still leave our kitty's SSs linked as learning tools for other members as most of us have a lot of data and also put a lot of observations and remarks on the SSs.
There is no way to, and the board was not intended to function in the manner, where every person discusses with another the advice to be given to ensure it is always the same.
It is your responsibility as a caregiver, to read the stickys and info posts, read the advice given to you, and then apply it to your kitty and your situation. It's always been a difficulty for all new members that they don't know whose advice or suggestions to trust. We all had to decide just as you do. This is where "know thy kitty" comes into play along with your own life situation.
I'm not going to throw Nan under the bus. She's very helpful and patient with many new members. But, my opinion differs based on my detailed knowledge of SLGS. Lots of midcyle tests don't replace the need for a weekly curve especially for a new member.
As I explained yesterday, it's important to know what is going on late in the cycle as well as midcyle. Perhaps as you get more data and knowledge, it "might" be fine to do some modifications. But just starting out, I think it's worthwhile to try and stick to the guidance as closely as you are able.
I can only guess that Veronica did not know you already had a condo started on 6/5 because she was responding to a discussion that started on 6/4 about syringes. It's for this very reason that the conversation should have been moved to your 6/5 condo. Don't be afraid to tell someone, politely, that you already have a condo for the current day and are moving the discussion there.
It has long been a guideline here that we do one condo per cat per day (
Making the Most of your Lantus/Levemir ISG Experience). If everyone started even two condos per day, so much info would get lost and we wouldn't be able to follow what was going on with that specific cat.
Please let me know if you have questions or I can help.