The Relion Confirm or Micro are the big favorites around here because the strips are affordable and they both take the smallest sample size. The meters are about $15 and strips are $35.88/100 (although in Hawaii, they may be more expensive....I know a lot of stuff is!)
You can also buy replacement strips that work in the Relion Confirm or Micro from American Diabetes Wholesale if you prefer not to shop at WalMart. Their Arkray Glucocard01 meter is the exact same meter as the Confirm.....Arkray makes the meter and WalMart re-brands it with their Relion name.
The Relion Prime takes a larger sample and we've heard some people get a lot of error messages, but others do fine with it...and it has the cheapest strips of all at $9 for 50
What's most important in choosing a meter is the cost and availability of the strips! Some of those meters have strips that are close to $1 each and when you test 4-6 times a day (or more) that runs into a lot of money