I am still using and loving the Boxie Cat litter and do see a difference between Elsey Cat Attract litter and this. Boxie is a little less dusty and I am using far less of the Boxie because it clumps tighter so it uses less content. I was up to a box and a half of Cat Attract per week where I am only using one bag per week of the Boxie. I do not have to scrape the sides nor spray the sides so I don't have to scrape the sides either so I have discarded the putty knife. I am still a fan of this litter.
After reading the recommendations on this thread for BoxieCat, I decided to give it a try, as Hannah also pees on the sides of the pan. I do like BoxieCat for the same reason... it doesn't stick to the pan and I don't end up scraping with an old pancake turner. I'm also not a big fan of spraying the kitty pan with cooking spray. I haven't really noticed that BoxieCat is less dusty, but the smaller granules definitely don't seem to track outside of the pan quite as much as our other litter, FreshStep. That stuff tracks everywhere.Thats what I love about the Boxie Cat. It doesn't stick to the sides (Katie pees in the corners or on the sides no matter how full or big the box), the clumps stay on top.
I hope you will like it. I just ordered another bag, this morning, too. For me, it definitely eliminates the 'putty' problem. Getting new pans is always a good idea, as after a while, old pans get all messed up after so much scraping, thus making them harder to clean. They also harbor a certain amount of bacteria, and that's not good, either. Let us know what you think about the BoxieCat. We hope Colby gives it his approval!I just ordered BoxieCat today too.