I would give insulin tonight, but a lot less. From looking at your first post, it looks like Smokey was 3.6 before his AM shot? For future reference, we ask new people to not give a shot if kitty is under 11.1 at shot time.
Without seeing the history of the previous curves, or knowing how Smokey arrived at the 5.5U of insulin, I would recommend a much reduced dose tonight, maybe 2 units or 2.5? If you are interested in sharing your test data with us so we can help provide more suggestions on dose, we use spreadsheets that you'll see in people's signature. To create a spreadsheet, here are the
instructions.
Cats are lucky in it is possible for cats to go into remission. With the proper diet, a better insulin, and following a dosing protocol this is possible for Smokey. Cats do best on low carb canned wet food or raw. You do not need to feed veterinary foods which are mostly of not great quality and are expensive. Here is a
list of commercial off the shelf wet foods. You want to look for something under 10% carbs. As BJM says, many people here use Friskies or Fancy Feast Pates, Wellness is also popular but there are others on the list. However, DO NOT switch foods unless you are doing regular blood testing as a change in foods away from dry can make a drastic difference. We had one member who recently did a dental for her cat and switched off dry food and within 24 hours went from 5.5U of Levemir to remission. It was a pretty scary 24 hours!
And as Oshawa Wendy suggests, talk to your vet about a better insulin. We started on Caninsulin but that insulin is really a dog insulin. It doesn't last long enough on most cats and has really steep drops and rises. That could be part of what you saw today. And cats on Caninsulin have a much higher percentage of hypo incidents. I saw one paper that said 30% of cats on Caninsulin had at least one hypo. Lantus and Levemir are available without prescription in pharmacies in Canada. Let us know if you want to go that route, we can help with dosing as we have much more experience with those insulins for cats.