Edith, I am totally gobsmacked. I checked the 2019 sheet when I looked before and I didn't see any data....it was a blank sheet. Goodness knows it would have been hard not to see all that colour! There have been some funky things happening with Google sheets lately. Alas I can see it now!
It looks to me like Norton may need a bit of a dose increase however, before you do that, it would be helpful if you could grab a few night time tests. Obviously you need your sleep but if you can grab a test before bed at +2, 3 or 4 hours after the night shot, it would help to fill in some of the puzzle. Kitties are notorious for going lower at night than they do during the day. Norton got down to blue the other day so I think it's worth trying to see what Norton does at night as it may help explain those high pre-shots.
The other thing that would be helpful is to grab some more tests during the day cycle. Some kitties hit peak insulin action (nadir) early and others a but later so if you make it a habit to grab a random test every day that you are available between +3 and +7, it will also help show what the Norton's pattern of action is.
Sliding scale dosing can work for some kitties but only after you have found the right dose that keeps kitty in good numbers for an optimum amount of time each day/night. Right now I think you still need to find the right dose and in order to do that, we need to figure out just how low the 1.75u is taking Norton during the cycles. Pre-shot testing tells you it is safe to give insulin however it's the mid cycle tests that will steer the dosing.
See what tests you can get in over the next couple of days and we'll revisit the dose question. I am a bit concerned that you may be looking at some glucose toxicity keeping his numbers up but I am equally concerned that he may be dipping lower than we think at night. It's also possible that Norton is one of those kitties for whom Caninsulin is just not long lasting enough and/or too fast acting to keep him from bouncing up at the end of each cycle in which case as was suggested, you might want to look at a longer lasting insulin like ProZinc, Lantus or Levemir. Not sure where you are located but if you are in the UK, your vet might be more willing to consider a change to ProZinc than the others long lasting insulins.