We've had a strange experience with their rabbit pate recently. We usually purchase cases of the smaller cans, but this is one time I bought a case of the 5oz cans. The 5oz cans all had a slightly different consistency, but was the same exact line of food. The cats wouldn't eat the cans from the 5oz case. I bought the smaller cans again, and the consistency was what they were used to, and they had no prob eating that. It was like we had an outlier batch of food with that larger case. So, just throwing my experience out there in case you changed what size of cans you purchased. The difference in consistency was hardly noticeable (I definitely noticed it, my bf couldn't tell the difference).