As the one who posted the "panicky thread', I can tell you that
1) each cat is different
2) things change - no cat is going to be 100% consistent
All it takes is one hairball, or something different in the food (manufacturers can make changes without changing the labeling for 6 months), or catching a kitty cold, or developing pancreatitis/IBD/something else, and what is safe one cycle is not safe the next. With only 5 days of data, with progressively lower starting numbers, I didn't want you waking up to a dead cat. And we have had folks with cats that hypo'd and passed away. Better I should put out a call for eyes, than risk you having that nightmare. Be upset with me if you want; I'm just glad your cat is doing OK.