For those of you having difficulty with finicky eaters

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jason & Belle (GA)

Member Since 2010
Hey all,

First I'd like to send my best to those of you struggling with kitty health issues, and those of you grieving a recent loss. I'm always here checking in and saying prayers for you all, even if you don't see me around.

As for finicky eaters, I've found something interesting with my two. You all know Gracie, my recently OTJ cat. When she was diabetic, she ate everything in sight, without hesitation. Once in remission, she stopped eating everything she was eating, and I've had difficulty finding anything, other than dry, that she'll eat. I also have Samantha, a mild CRF, IBD 15-17yo cat that used to eat anything before dx, but now likes very little. I have literally bought everything on Tanya's CRF list and Janet and Binky's. I also bought a ton of stuff from Petco and Petsmart that seemed decent. No kidding, at any given time, I have 20-30 different kinds of food in the house for just those two.

Since I sit with them when they eat, I noticed that they moved their food around a lot in the bowl, pushing it with their tongue, sort of licking. They wouldn't actually eat it, but they didn't turn up their noses. I decided to see if pureeing the food would get that licking motion to lead to ingesting. Turned out the same food they refused to eat out of the can got the bowls licked clean when pureed. Same exact food, no additives other than a little water. I used to spend hours trying to get them to eat, sprinkling all kinds of stuff on the food. Pureed, they eat that same food without hesitation. Now I just buy one can of each food I want to try, and if they show any interest in it, I puree it and try again. So far, I've probably tried this with 10 foods, and it's worked with 8 or so. We all know how much our cats like gravy, so maybe they think this is a whole bowl full of it!

I hope this helps some of you out there. I struggled for two years to get Samantha to eat consistently, and for the last few months to get Gracie to eat low carb, non-dry food. Not only are they eating a proper diet for their conditions, it saves me a ton of time trying to get them to eat. I have one of those little rocket blenders, and it does the trick. It works for pate and chunky foods. Good luck!

Jason
 
For the first few weeks I had to mash the food with a fork, add warm water, and mix to an equal consistency, just to get Noxin to eat his wet food. Worked wonders. Now he is a little less picky.

Since I am trying to free feed, I now try to only mix with cold water, if I am going to be away for more than a few hours and leaving enough that I don't think they will finish it anytime soon. I know in human food the warmer temperatures and wet surfaces encourage bacterial growth; but I don't know if it makes any kind of difference with their cat food. I know many people here have mentioned that they have had experience leaving wet out for quite a while with no indication of spoilage.
 
I wonder if a Foley food mill would work well enough. (for those who don't know what one is, its like a large bowl with strainer holes and a slanted paddle which is turned, pushing the food through the holes)
 
Great reminder.. I know that this is one of the options when transitioning a challenging kitty from dry to wet that is given in Health. To mix the food with water & blend it - voila, a kitty shake ;-)
I hear you loud & clear on picky eaters.. My Sadi is a constant challenge & I easily have enough cans to look like I am feeding a colony & am known on a first name basis by every pet store in a 30 mile radius :oops:
 
Wellness is a great brand to use for this...the consistency is perfect for just mashing and stirring water in with a spoon - no mixer needed. Muffin still insists hers be mixed as well, and she loves it.
 
I agree with Anne. I feed different flavors of Wellness and just keep a bottle of water on the counter to mix with it. Spoon some food in the dish, add some water, and just stir it up with a spoon. My cat ate it straight out of the can, but he's always so hungry that I felt adding the water might fill him up a bit more. Also, if you add water, you don't have to worry whether they're drinking out of the water bowls as much!!
 
Anne&Muffin said:
Wellness is a great brand to use for this...the consistency is perfect for just mashing and stirring water in with a spoon - no mixer needed. Muffin still insists hers be mixed as well, and she loves it.


So far, Gracie loves the blended Wellness, and Samantha loves Friskies Special Diet Meaty bits with Chicken(very low in phosphorus), Innova Cat & Kitten(blend in a phosphorus binder), and Solid Gold Chicken, Turkey, White Fish and Liver. They will only eat them blended though. I do have to use the mini blender since they will leave any bits that aren't blended. I struggled for so long and never imagined it wasn't necessarily the food they didn't like, but the consistency.

Jason
 
BJM said:
I wonder if a Foley food mill would work well enough. (for those who don't know what one is, its like a large bowl with strainer holes and a slanted paddle which is turned, pushing the food through the holes)

I just looked one up, and although I think it would work, the size of the milling area would probably create a real mess and cause you to leave quite a bit of food behind. When I add some water, I still only get about 5.5oz out of the blender. leaving a little behind.
 
just thinking out loud - do you think there are any mouth/dental problems behind this? i mean it seems strange that a cat would want their food blenderized when in nature, they'd be shredding a mouse or a snake.
 
Good point, Julie.. because it never worked for mine & I tried it again today just to see.. nope, nothing worked. They each prefer chunky & even then it is a challenge. I envy those who have kitties who eat well.
 
julie1220 said:
just thinking out loud - do you think there are any mouth/dental problems behind this? i mean it seems strange that a cat would want their food blenderized when in nature, they'd be shredding a mouse or a snake.

I thought about mentioning dental issues, but in my case, both were checked for dental issues in the last few weeks and came up clean. Strangely, both still love eating dry food, which obviosly can't be licked. I can't explain why they will only eat the pureed form of some foods, but I'm hoping its the same for others that are having problems.
 
Kitty wanted dry food even when his teeth were awful. I don't know what they put in that stuff, but I sure wish he had some gusto for his wet food. (Or wait, maybe I should be careful what I wish for. He's hefty already! :mrgreen: )

I like the idea of getting it pureed without having to add a ton of water. Kitty rejected soupy too.

Of course, if it has chicken dust on it, he'll eat anything that sticks to the chicken dust. :lol:
 
Kathy and Kitty said:
Kitty wanted dry food even when his teeth were awful. I don't know what they put in that stuff, but I sure wish he had some gusto for his wet food. (Or wait, maybe I should be careful what I wish for. He's hefty already! :mrgreen: )

I like the idea of getting it pureed without having to add a ton of water. Kitty rejected soupy too.

Of course, if it has chicken dust on it, he'll eat anything that sticks to the chicken dust. :lol:


Samantha loves Salmon dust, and I'd get so excited that she was eating that I kept piling it on. Turns out I was feeding her mostly Salmon dust though since the majority of the food was always left in the bottom of the bowl :) So far with the pureeing, I haven't had to resort to any dust or flavor enhancers.
 
Jason, thanks for mentioning that you had the same "dust" issue!

I don't know what kind of machine you're using to puree, but I'll find one.

Do you puree just one portion at a time, or a whole can, and refrigerate what you don't use?
 
Kathy and Kitty said:
Jason, thanks for mentioning that you had the same "dust" issue!

I don't know what kind of machine you're using to puree, but I'll find one.

Do you puree just one portion at a time, or a whole can, and refrigerate what you don't use?


I have something similar to a rocket blender. The blender blades screw on top of a cup and you turn it upside down to blend. It has different size cups. I blend the whole can at once. I bought those small reusable glad containers and they are perfect for storing. I think it was two dollars for six of them. I stick them in the fridge and the food solidifies, making it easier to get out. I microwave for roughly 13 seconds, stir, and serve.

Jason
 
Thanks for the equipment specs, Jason, and the cooking instructions! :mrgreen: I'm going to look for one of those blenders.

So we become chefs for the kittehs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top