Hi Jenny,
Sorry to hear that you are having a hard time with your vet. My vet supported at home testing, but not to the extent that I have and I am so glad I followed what I learned here. Jack is in remission.
I have both the AlphaTrak and the ReliOn Confirm.
Jack was my first to be diagnosed and I not knowing what, where, when or how to do anything, I just went with the AlphaTrak. After finding FDMB, I got educated in the ways of Diabetes.
I had tested Samantha with Jacks meter prior to her DX and knew she was diabetic as well. I realized the AlphaTrak was going to cost a lot more than the ReliOn but that really had nothing to do with it. I wanted to use a meter whereby the people here have more experience with and having a backup meter I thought, was a good idea. I still have purchased AlphaTrak Strips for Jack.
I have kept each patients numbers on their own meter. I have snuck a reading or 2 with each, on the others meter, just to confirm what I have seen here and I am comfortable with results.
At the low end, I did a test and found that the AlphaTrak read 136, the ReliOn 88. Based upon the information that BJM provided it was spot on. 136 X .65 =88.4. Close enough for me. BJM did say that one test does not confirm everything and I understand and agree but in this instance it was valid in my book.
I also realize that based upon BJM's information, the 280 ReliOn should read 430 on the AlphaTrak, that is where this gets a little hairy and for that I have no answer.
What I have read here and believe is, that whatever meter you use, the important information are the readings over time and their relation to each other. Have they gone up, gone down or stayed the same. This is important when giving insulin. I think that the 50 -130 Human Meter and the 76 - 180 for AlphaTrak are your targets. They are mine.
My suggestion, Use the ReliOn, do your own curve with unabashed numbers. I have put my faith in the people here that they know what they are talking about and that they will be the ones to help you through. They have been there for me and I have no doubt they (and myself) will be there for you.
All the best,
Kevin