Wow, nice cycle so far, Alicia. What are you feeding at +1? Hope it slows down the radical drops and bounces. We have them too many times. I keep getting advice to only feed higher carbs if under 50 or so on a handheld. I'm so confused by all of this

Safe surfing there, Kit. Have a nice day, Alicia

I'm sort of playing with a couple different percentages, and will adjust as, hopefully, her numbers get back to where she was pre UTI. At the moment, I'm feeding 3% at preshot, and 9% at +1 and sometimes +2 if she's starting pretty high. I swap to 5-6% if she seems to be leveling down okay at +2 or 3. And when she hits greens (or seems to have leveled off) I switch back to 3%. At least, that's what I'm doing at the moment. She would prefer a diet of freeze dried salmon, chicken, and sirloin only. But this is why I'm in charge of her feeding, and not her.
I know it's confusing, I've been lurking and following (I'm back at work and my brain is struggling to get back into work mode because hello again stress). I think most folks are feeding lower carbs than you do, since you're regularly feed more like 6%, right? So 9 and 12% feel huge if you're regularly feeding 1-3%. I think you're working with a raw diet, which I have zero experience with, but the way I've been looking at it is give just enough higher to sort of curb the drop, not stop it. And because I'm playing with pates or easily smooshable foods (again, zero idea of what the consistency of the food you're working with is like), I can sort of mix and match percentages to get a different on (at least that's how my brain sees it). Like, I still want to get to lower numbers, I just want it to be a bit slower. And the higher carb stuff takes longer to work through the system (in theory, which cats love to negate what should be a thing). And some days it works, and some days she still dives right down or takes those carbs and runs.
When I was talking to Angela about it, she had asked me how long I had done the previous experiment with food, and I thought 2 weeks was a pretty long time, and she said sometimes it can take a month or more to see the actual results (I am not patient enough for all of this, but I'm trying!).
I don't know if any of that helped, but I see you doing what you can with a fractious cat, and I know you're trying your best. And really what else can we do?

