I don't know.... I think she's going to run into trouble shooting 1.25 at 200. But I'll defer to your experience.
It does depend on being able to monitor and knowing your cat, for sure. Some cats are bouncier and more caution is needed, but in general, this is still a fairly low dose, and fairly high numbers. My understanding with vetsulin (and correct me if I'm wrong), is that the insulin kicks in pretty much right away, so the pre-shot number is the number that is acted on.
With prozinc, and when a kitty is climbing the dosing scale, before regulation, the onset isn't (usually) until closer to +2, which means that the pre-shot number indicates if you're in safe ranges, but the number acted on is almost always higher because the kitty is fed at shot time, numbers climb from there, and then the insulin kicks in. So a pre-shot of 200 isn't the number the insulin acts on -- that number comes later. So the nadir is used more heavily at that stage to determine how a dose is doing.
Caveats: when the kitty starts healing and the pancreas is helping out more. Then we don't always know from cycle to cycle how much help the cat is going to give him/herself. So the pre-shot number becomes much more important at that point. Or if a cat has long cycles, so that the insulin is kicking in before it has really had a chance to rise from the previous cycle. Or if there is variation in the shot time so that you end up with overlap.
I realize there are a LOT of "or this....or that..." involved in all of this.
We don't have a lot of data on Izzy yet, so it is a little hard to predict at this point. One clarification for Lauren is that I said, "soon" for the increase, not "now"

So please do keep an eye on the numbers tonight. I had a few more questions for you first...
That being said, I think Izzy will be fine tonight, just make sure to grab that +3 before you hit the sack.
And now for the questions for Lauren:
1. Is there variation in your shot times? Or are they pretty precisely at 12/12? Prozinc can tolerate some variation, but I'm wondering if that might have been a factor in the 5/14 cycle.
2. How is your schedule looking like this weekend? You don't need to do another full curve, but if you can keep grabbing a +3/+5/+7 or a +4/+6 through the weekend it would really help. You do have some curious patterns that make me want to make sure that the curve you did was representative and not a wonky cycle.
And one thing to keep in mind - you generally want to do dose increases on cycles you can monitor. If you go to sleep at +3 tonight, Izzy will hit nadir without you being able to monitor. Probably okay, but we aim for safety which means increasing when you can check around the nadir and make sure the increase is okay. Please don't stress about it, there is a lot to learn around here! Do take some time to read through the stickies though to get an understanding of how Prozinc works, and then ask as many questions as you have.