Hi Victoria! I'm so sorry to hear you're feeling overwhelmed. In order to get Buttons' numbers down, there are a few things you're going to need to do.
First, please read the stickies at the top of the Prozinc forum to educate yourself about how this insulin works and how we recommend dosing. The more you know and understand, the better you'll be able to help your kitty. As you read, make note of any questions you have and ask them. We are happy to help clarify.
Second, you need to get mid-cycle tests whenever you can. That includes during the evening cycle. You're testing before each shot which is great, so keep doing that. But in order to know if a dose is working, we need to see those mid-cycle numbers too. You've done a few which is helpful, so keep it up, and start getting a before-bed test each night as well. There is often a difference between the daytime numbers and the nighttime numbers.
Third, we recommend moving the dose based on data, in a relatively systematic way. Right now it looks like you have bounced around a bit from 1.0 to 1.5 to 2.0. Moving the dose around like that can be hard on your kitty and also make it hard to figure out the right dose. It does look like Buttons is going to need more insulin, but in order to keep her safe, you need to be testing and only increase by 0.25 every three to six cycles - not just moving it around from cycle to cycle.
I would recommend getting a mid-cycle test today if you can, then get the pre-shot this evening and a before bed test. Stick with 2.0 for tonight (assuming you have a normal PMPS number) and post your numbers. Then tomorrow post again and we can start to help you find a better dose to bring those numbers down.