Here are my thoughts having checked out Teasel's spreadsheet and reviewing your notes re: your experience with Lantus.
I agree with Bobbie that getting some earlier and later cycle tests might shed some light on what's going on with Teasel. Teasel looks much like Citrus, the cat I assisted with on ProZinc...bouncing wildly and oh how I feel for you!

It's royally frustrating and worrisome.
When you were using Lantus, your dose adjustments were by 0.5u rather than by 0.25u (a little eyestrain required but doable) so I can't help but wonder if some of what you were seeing was too high a dose rather than too little and if you might have skipped over the ideal dose for Teasel.
I have a high dose cat with IAA and can truly relate to the frustration you are feeling. I used Lantus previously and now Levemir. At my girl's doses, (she got up to 16u BID) I could have made adjustments by up to 1 or more units at a time but I found all that did was cause her to have major bounces and we went up and down.. repeat... repeat. Taught me you can't rush anything with these sugar kids.
It may be that Teasel is one of those cats that craves consistency but he also is very sensitive to dose changes. While you are able to adjust doses a little more finely with ProZinc and you have held doses at times, there are other times when doses have changed quite a bit over a few cycles and I think his body may be finding that confusing. I can see why you changed the dose in many instances but in some cases, I admit I was a bit puzzled.
The other thing I would suggest you think about, given the difficulty you are having regulating him and his wild swings, is having him checked for Acromegaly. This likely is a long shot because it's generally considered to be a high dose condition designated by requiring over 6u BID by vets but that isn't always the case. Acromegaly is a pulsative condition meaning things change depending on how much growth hormone is being pumped into the system on any given day. Acromegaly is a co-morbid condition in up to 25% of diabetic cats.
How is Teasel's weight? If he's gaining despite the lack of regulation, that could be another sign that acromegaly may be in the picture.
The test for Acromegaly is relatively inexpensive and most of the cost is the blood draw and the transport of the sample because it can only be done at the University of Michigan. The caveat to this test is that if you take blood on a day when the pulsative activity is low, the test may be erroneously negative.
If he were my cat, I'd give Lantus or Levemir another go finessing doses by 0.25u at a time and get the acro testing done because if he does have acro, at least you'll know why he is so erratic and believe me, just knowing what you are dealing with can relieve a lot of the stress and worry we go through with our hard to regulate furkids. .
