Would You Rather (day late!)

[Sarah and Buzz]

Would you rather eat 30 lbs of cheese in one sitting, or a 5 gallon bucket of peanut butter (without water)?

 

[Ele & Blackie (GA)]

Those choices, suck, Sarah. But I think I'll go with the peanut butter. I think the cheese might make you feel bad for days. :lol:

 

[LynnLee + Mousie]

neither????

if i have to choose i think i'd go with the cheese. eaten slow enough it's not too bad i suppose.

orrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr, since your question specifically says peanut butter without water, could i have some celery or another beverage with it??? if so, i might be swayed to go with the peanut butter

 

[Sarah and Buzz]

Those choices, suck, Sarah. But I think I'll go with the peanut butter. I think the cheese might make you feel bad for days. :lol:

They do suck, but if they didn't, there wouldn't be much to think about!

 

[Sarah and Buzz]

neither????

if i have to choose i think i'd go with the cheese. eaten slow enough it's not too bad i suppose.

orrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr, since your question specifically says peanut butter without water, could i have some celery or another beverage with it??? if so, i might be swayed to go with the peanut butter

I think in the spirit of things, you could have celery but not another beverage.

 

[Sarah and Buzz]

Now sitting and thinking about them, I do have to agree with Ele that the choices suck.

I guess I would go with the cheese. Ele's right, it could cause problems for days, but think about 5 gallons of peanut butter! I mean, that wouldn't be pretty on the digestive system either. But god, 30 lbs of cheese. I LOVE cheese, but that's a lot. Urgh.

 

[Donna & Buddha]

You gotta tell me, how'd you come up with this one?

I'm not choosing, I'd be dead afterwards either way, and I love both cheese and pb.

 

[Ele & Blackie (GA)]

And not only would you be sick, but you'd be fat too! :mrgreen:

 

[FurballLover]

OK-just spent 10min thinkin' about that one!!
Guess I would have to say cheese.

I have a theory that if you dipped 1/2 the world in chz, and the other half in chocolate--there would be no more war!
I own/operate an ice cream & burger restaurant and I have to admit I've never understood how one can eat a burger without cheese!! The funny thing is, my DH is lactose intolerant and married the ice cream lady!

 

[Gator & H (GA)]

Peanut butter and milk please [as long as it is the real peanut butter and that that hydrogenated crud]! YUMMMMM!

 

[Karen & Angus(GA)]

I think I have already done both. I would probably go with the peanut butter.

 

[Sarah and Buzz]

I think I have already done both. I would probably go with the peanut butter.

Then you should be able to answer the question of which is harder on your insides. Although I'm guessing our answer lies in your choice.

 

[Joanna & Bix (GA)]

I have a theory that if you dipped 1/2 the world in chz, and the other half in chocolate--there would be no more war!

I love it!!!! LOL! I'd like to be in the chocolate hemisphere, please!

I pick peanut butter & celery... yum!!! And since it's one sitting, but no time limit specified, I think I would stock up on movies from the library & make an all-day party out of it! No way I could fit all that pb in in a short time and not blow up, little sticky pieces of me spattered all around the living room! Ewwwwwwww!!!!! First I was going to pick cheese, but I just can't even picture 30 lbs, makes me want to hurl just thinking about it. And I love cheese, well at least I used to before today's challenge made me rethink that! :lol:

 

[Sarah and Buzz]

You guys crack me up! I don't know what I would do without this place somedays, really. I can always count on PZI Land to cheer me up. Thank you all!

 

[Joanna & Bix (GA)]

Well I suspect we'd be a lot more boring without your challenging us in these somewhat bizarre ways, lol! :mrgreen: Keep 'em coming.... I already building up my strength for whatever freaky choice I may be forced to make next week!

 

[Sarah and Buzz]

I like a girl who thinks ahead!

 

[Karen & Angus(GA)]

Then you should be able to answer the question of which is harder on your insides. Although I'm guessing our answer lies in your choice.

I don't know if peanut butter is an easier on your insides, but it is certainly quicker.