Hi Ryn,
I'm not experienced at reading spreadsheets at all - hopefully someone with more experience will be along to confirm what I am about to say.
Can I assume you are using the SLGS protocol for Grayson? It looks like you are home a lot to test. Since his nadirs are not that low, if he were my cat I would do a .25 increase and test from mid cycle to see how he is doing on that dose. Hold for a at least I'd say 10 cycles (5 days) until you know his reaction.
When I had Genghis on Caninsulin, I changed over to 100U syringes (cheaper at Shoppers than the 40U at the vet's) and made the conversion with this chart:
Make sure you get 3/10 mL syringes with half unit markings (just ask the pharmacist - the BD Ultrafine with 8mm 31 G needle works nicely for Genghis.
If you wanted to up Grayson's dose to 1.25, you measure out a tiny smidge over 3 units on a U100 syringe. The key is to be consistent in how you measure it.
I'm not sure if Caninsulin dose is also increased or decreased based on the LOWEST point, not the pre-shot but from what I've read, this is the safest course of action. The pre-shot will only tell you if you should shoot or not (generally with limited data, your no shoot value is 200 or 11.2 or so). He seems to peak around +4 (although Genghis it was all over the place, even with consistent feed times) so be prepared to test at +4 and spot check /monitor him elsewhere for a few days.
I'm assuming you feed ½ hour before you shoot (and test at that time as well, i.e. don't wait the half hour before you test). This will help with the steep drop Caninsulin can produce with food in Grayson's tummy working away when the Caninsulin hits around +2, with peak action from +4 through +6 (ish) - every cat is different!
Can I say that I am a strong advocate of using Lantus? Have a quick look at how Genghis did on Caninuslin, higher pre-shots, middling nadirs, then back up again. Then Lantus. Smooooth sailing. Every cat is different but if you think Grayson feels good now, just wait until you can get him in the blues and greens for a while! Just a thought!