Lori, my Ali was strictly a temptations type of gal and would NEVER touch any other treat, no matter what. I offered them to her, but she would just sniff then stick her nose up in the air. I have been giving the fishy flakes to Spot and Ralph for about a year now and I've offered them to her throughout that time, but again, nose up in the air. Now, all of a sudden, when she knows the other two are getting fishy flakes, she's right there along side them, waiting for her little morsel. She also wouldn't touch the FD livers, but now she demands them to be sprinkled on top of her food at meal time. Sometimes that's the only way I can get her to eat. She also enjoyed the Salmon. And the FD Chicken....well, let me tell you......she's just as much of a hoover as her bigger brothers. So, Ginger may very well become a treataholic if you purchase any of those!