Shaak loved the Duck Liver pure bites, I didn't get them for her often but she would drag the package of bites that I placed in a zipper medicine bag with her to try and get into the Duck Liver pure bites, more than once at night I would wake up to her dragging the bag across the bed trying to get into the bag. I gave her the chicken and shrimp bites more often. I got the cat ones but lots of people here say the dog ones are a better price per ounce.