My hunch is that the second test is more accurate since the first test strip was a little wonky. The only way to know for sure would do the best two-out-of-three, but that would require another poke, and it isn't really necessary. Both numbers are high enough to give the full dose, and that's really all you needed to know anyway.
As for how much to test, I think a lot of it depends on the kitty. My diabetic, Sam, hates being tested. He's a good sport and cooperates well enough now, but if I never tested him again he'd be very happy. My other cat however, doesn't feel it at all. I could stab him 100 times/day and he'd just lay there and keep purring. So if Gizmo is doing fine and you're just feeling bad, keep testing. If he's bothered by it though, I think you'd be fine to test a little less. How much less is really hard at the beginning to know. Based on the numbers you're seeing right now, I think if you tested once or twice in the cycle that would be enough. Just move around when you test. So one cycle you might try +4 and +6, another cycle +5 and +7, another cycle +3 and +????....And then if you have an unusual number (for example when you start shooting on yellows) then you might test more on those cycles.