Ry:
I don't think that is a sign of hypo....56 is a very normal and safe number. Some of the OTJ kitties test in the 40s and some of the current lantus/lev kitties with experienced beans who know how to manage their curves will surf safely in the 40s.
We don't know what Scooter's threshold for hypo symptoms might be but I *doubt* you would see them in the 50s. Most typically, we see some kitties having different behaviours if their numbers drop suddenly. Some kitties meow, some are hungry, some get really "rowdy", and some, like Gracie, don't let the beans know when the number is coming down. Perhaps Scooter could tell and so he wanted to let Ben know he needed food.
One of the things I was taught when Grace was on lantus and which I find to be invaluable is to always get a +2. If Scooter's +2 is not almost the same as his PS, then you can anticipate that he might come down and then you can do additional testing. Because his +3 was 106, I'm thinking you would have seen a +2 that was much lower than his PMPS. Then you can judge whether to stay up or not. And you will also learn his patterns...how long does it typically take him to clear a bounce, etc.
Good job last night...I agree with Sienne. In the 50s, I would have just given him a tsp of his regular LC food to see if he would surf. But I know how scary that number is the first time in the middle of the night so big KUDOS to Ben for testing and feeding him!!